Recruited for a secret experiment, a young artist steps from modern Manhattan into the gaslit streets of 1880s New York—where beauty, romance, and danger wait around every corner. Time and Again is a transporting time-travel tale rich with historical detail and the wonder of walking into the past.
Have you read this book? Share what you liked (or didn’t), and we’ll use your answers to recommend your next favorite read!
These picks are popular with readers who enjoyed this book. Complete a quick Shelf Talk to get recommendations made just for you! Warning: possible spoilers for Time and Again below.
If you loved how Si Morley literally walks into 1880s Manhattan from the Dakota and falls for Julia while wrestling with whether to alter history, you’ll click with 11/22/63. Jake Epping steps through a portal to late‑1950s America, painstakingly learns the era’s rhythms, and faces the same pull between personal happiness and the consequences of changing the past—only this time the target is the JFK assassination. It’s the same blend of tactile period detail, romance, and moral stakes that made Si’s trips so absorbing.
One joy of Time and Again is soaking in Si’s street‑level tour of 1880s New York—the shop windows, omnibuses, and period photographs—until you feel the cobblestones underfoot. Doomsday Book delivers that same transportive texture as historian Kivrin is sent to medieval England and must navigate village life, faith, and illness with only her wits. Like Si’s careful preparations with Dr. Danziger’s project, Kivrin’s training and on‑the‑ground observations make the past feel astonishingly real.
If what drew you in was Si’s close, personal narration—his growing bond with Julia and the small, human consequences of slipping between eras—then The Time Traveler’s Wife will resonate. Henry’s involuntary time jumps complicate his relationship with Clare in deeply personal ways, much like Si’s dilemma of building a life in 1880s New York. The focus stays on hearts and choices rather than gadgets, echoing the gentle, intimate pull you felt with Si and Julia.
Part of the charm of Time and Again is hearing the story straight from Si Morley—his wry asides about the Project at the Dakota, his awe on those first walks down 1880s Broadway. In The Door Into Summer, engineer Dan Davis narrates his own leap across decades with a voice every bit as engaging, unraveling betrayals and second chances through time. If you enjoyed being inside Si’s head as he navigated past and present, Dan’s conversational, hands-on narration will feel like old company.
Si’s adventure begins with a mysterious old letter and turns into an investigation that sends him threading through 1880s Manhattan, following leads and risking entanglements. The Jane Austen Project mirrors that investigative pulse: two scholars travel to 1815 to befriend Austen, recover a lost manuscript, and quietly diagnose her illness—all while keeping their cover. If you liked how Si sleuthed through history without breaking it, you’ll savor the careful clues, forged identities, and ethical tightrope here.
Unlock your personalized book recommendations! Just take a quick Shelf Talk for Time and Again by Jack Finney. It’s only a few questions and takes less than a minute.