Ask My Shelf
Log in Register
Ask My Shelf

Share your thoughts in a quick Shelf Talk!

The Winter People by Jennifer McMahon

In a Vermont town divided by past and present, a series of eerie disappearances echoes an old tragedy. Journal pages and whispered legends converge as a grieving family seeks the truth in winter’s grip. The Winter People is a chilling, atmospheric mystery where the dead are never entirely gone.

Have you read this book? Share what you liked (or didn’t), and we’ll use your answers to recommend your next favorite read!

Love The Winter People but not sure what to read next?

These picks are popular with readers who enjoyed this book. Complete a quick Shelf Talk to get recommendations made just for you! Warning: possible spoilers for The Winter People below.

In The Winter People, did you enjoy ...

... the creepy diary-and-ledger clues that unravel Sara Harrison Shea’s past?

The Silent Companions by Laura Purcell

If the way Sara Harrison Shea’s journal entries drip-fed you the truth — guiding Ruthie and Katherine through West Hall’s secrets — had you riveted, you’ll love how The Silent Companions uses 17th‑century diaries and household ledgers to peel back a country estate’s history. As Elsie explores a locked room and discovers both painted wooden "companions" and damning pages from the past, the evidence builds with the same chilling, paper‑trail intimacy that made Sara’s writings so irresistible.

... the past–present braid of timelines that steadily closes a cold case no one understands?

The Sun Down Motel by Simone St. James

If you liked how The Winter People toggles between Sara in 1908 and the present-day hunt for Alice, The Sun Down Motel mirrors that rhythm. In 1982, Viv vanishes while working the night shift; in 2017, her niece Carly takes the same job to chase the truth. The dual narratives lock together clue by clue — much like Ruthie’s search echoing Sara’s — as ghostly phenomena and small-town rot converge into one satisfying reveal.

... an isolated New England town hiding rituals and secrets you only uncover by sleuthing?

The Night Strangers by Chris Bohjalian

If Ruthie’s investigation into Alice’s disappearance and the sinister lore around West Hall’s stone circle hooked you, The Night Strangers delivers that same unraveling dread. After a pilot survives a crash and relocates with his family to a creaky Victorian in New Hampshire, strange neighbors — and a basement door sealed with 39 bolts — set off a slow-burn inquiry into the town’s macabre customs and the house’s past, culminating in revelations as startling as the "sleepers" ritual.

... the bleak, rule-less resurrection lore in the woods and its terrible costs?

Pet Sematary by Stephen King

If the stone ring in the forest and the whispered promise of "bringing them back" in The Winter People gave you chills, Pet Sematary is the harrowing next step. When Louis Creed learns what lies beyond the deadfall — and what comes home after burial — the story digs into the same irresistible, folklore‑steeped temptation that animates the "sleepers," then pushes it to a devastating conclusion.

... the slow, suffocating dread of a haunting that may have no safe explanation?

The Little Stranger by Sarah Waters

If the grim, wintry atmosphere of West Hall — the farmhouse, the locked rooms, the sense that grief itself might be haunting the living — lingered with you, The Little Stranger amplifies that mood. As Dr. Faraday is drawn into the crumbling Hundreds Hall, inexplicable burns, bells, and writing on walls accumulate with the same stark, skin‑prickling inevitability that shadowed Sara’s house, blurring the line between psychological scars and something truly malignant.

Unlock your personalized book recommendations! Just take a quick Shelf Talk for The Winter People by Jennifer McMahon. It’s only a few questions and takes less than a minute.