If you were captivated by the enigmatic White People manuscript and Machen's chilling atmosphere, you'll find The King in Yellow equally haunting. Chambers weaves together a collection of interconnected stories centered on a fictional play said to induce madness, blending supernatural dread with the uncanny. The lingering sense of cosmic horror and the unknown will resonate with your taste for the eldritch.

If you enjoyed Machen's gradual escalation of unease in stories like "The White People," you'll be enthralled by The Willows. Blackwood's novella immerses you in the eerie wilderness of the Danube, where two travelers encounter a pervasive, inexplicable terror. The sense of isolation and the barely-glimpsed forces at work create a mood that lingers long after reading.

If you appreciated Machen's exploration of metaphysical and existential questions—like the blurred line between good and evil or the nature of the supernatural—The Fisherman will draw you in. Langan's novel delves deep into the emotional lives of its characters while spinning a terrifying tale about ancient, unknowable powers lurking beneath the surface of reality.

If you were fascinated by Machen's use of symbolism, especially in stories like "The Great God Pan," The House on the Borderland offers a surreal, visionary journey that blurs reality and allegory. The unnamed narrator’s descent into otherworldly realms and encounters with strange creatures create a vivid, haunting allegory of cosmic insignificance and the unknown.

If you relished the uncertain reality and unreliable perspectives in Machen's tales—particularly the ambiguous narration of "The White People"—The Turn of the Screw will intrigue you. James crafts a chilling ghost story through the eyes of a governess whose credibility is constantly in question, leaving you to puzzle over what is real and what is imagined.