If you loved following Miss Penelope Lumley’s determined efforts to civilize the wild Incorrigible children while solving the peculiar mysteries of Ashton Place, you’ll enjoy The Willoughbys by Lois Lowry. In this book, a group of siblings embarks on their own mission to find new parents, all while navigating the eccentricities of their oddball family. The children’s goal-driven antics and clever schemes will keep you engaged as they work toward their unusual objective.

If you enjoyed the dynamic between Miss Lumley and the three Incorrigibles, you’ll love The Penderwicks. This charming story centers on four spirited sisters and their dog as they navigate adventures and mischief during a summer holiday. The ensemble cast’s witty banter and heartfelt teamwork are reminiscent of the camaraderie and chaos at Ashton Place.

If Penelope Lumley’s journey from inexperienced governess to confident caretaker captured your heart, you’ll appreciate The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. Young Calpurnia, curious and determined, learns about the natural world—and herself—over a transformative summer. Her growth, much like Miss Lumley’s, is both touching and inspiring.

If you delighted in the clever wordplay and sly humor of The Mysterious Howling—from Miss Lumley’s earnest lessons to the children’s canine shenanigans—you’ll be charmed by The Bad Beginning. Lemony Snicket’s unique narration style, full of tongue-in-cheek commentary and absurd situations, brings a similar wit and levity to the plight of the Baudelaire orphans.

If you were captivated by the mysterious manor and lush grounds of Ashton Place, you’ll be enchanted by The Secret Garden. The story’s detailed worldbuilding brings Misselthwaite Manor and its hidden garden to vivid life, immersing you in the wonders and secrets of its English countryside setting.