If you were captivated by the mysterious powers and mythological underpinnings of The Library at Mount Char—where Carolyn and her foster siblings wield unfathomable abilities doled out by their enigmatic 'Father'—you'll be drawn into American Gods. Neil Gaiman unfolds a world packed with ancient deities living among mortals, blending Americana and myth into a gripping, darkly magical journey across the U.S. Shadow Moon’s quest to make sense of the impossible echoes Carolyn’s own unsettling discoveries.

If you relished the grimly funny tone and absurd situations in The Library at Mount Char—from Carolyn’s matter-of-fact attitude toward violence to the strange bureaucracy of her world—The Rook will delight you. You’ll follow Myfanwy Thomas as she navigates a secret government agency battling supernatural threats, all while dealing with memory loss and hilariously awkward predicaments. The blend of deadpan humor and dark, weird happenings is pitch-perfect.

If you loved the intricate, eerie universe of The Library at Mount Char—with its bizarre Library, shifting rules, and hidden histories—you'll be mesmerized by Neverwhere. Gaiman’s London Below is a vividly realized world beneath London’s streets, filled with dangerous characters, cryptic rules, and a sense of wonder tinged with menace. Richard Mayhew’s plunge into this secret society mirrors Carolyn’s initiation into the Library’s mysteries.

If you were fascinated by the flawed, disturbing cast of The Library at Mount Char—where Carolyn and her siblings commit acts both horrifying and sympathetic—The Secret History will draw you in. Tartt’s tightly-knit group of classics students descend into murder and betrayal, their actions guided by ambiguous ethics and hidden motives. The psychological complexity and shifting loyalties echo the unsettling dynamics of Hawkins’s novel.

If the mind-bending plot turns and shocking revelations in The Library at Mount Char kept you turning pages—like the true nature of the Library and Father’s identity—Annihilation will grip you. VanderMeer’s novel plunges you into Area X, a mysterious wilderness where nothing is what it seems and reality itself warps around the biologist protagonist. The constant sense of unease and unpredictability is deeply compelling.