If Towner’s fractured recollections, evasions, and the way her story about Eva’s disappearance kept shifting under Rafferty’s scrutiny hooked you, you’ll love how Shutter Island lets U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels investigate a vanished patient while his own memory and perceptions keep betraying him. Like the lace-reading that may or may not reveal truth, every clue on the island demands you question who’s telling the story—and why—right up to the final gut-punch.

You liked how The Lace Reader braided Towner’s return to Salem with buried family history—Eva’s past, May’s secrets, and the shadow of Cal’s influence. In The Thirteenth Tale, a biographer unravels a famous novelist’s tangled, time-hopping confession. As with Towner’s flashbacks and withheld truths, each jump in time reshapes what you think you know, building toward revelations that make earlier scenes hit twice as hard.

If you connected to the raw interiority of Towner—her grief, dissociation, and hard-won self-understanding amid Eva’s absence and Salem’s pressures—The Weight of Water delivers a similarly intimate unspooling. A photographer investigates a century-old New England murder while her present-day relationship buckles; the narrative probes memory and blame with the same piercing emotional honesty that made Towner’s healing arc so compelling.

Drawn to the way lace-reading sits on the border of intuition and the uncanny, and how Salem’s past shades Towner’s present? In The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane, a grad student uncovers a colonial-era witch’s legacy that may carry real power. The book balances research, hidden journals, and generational secrets much like the Whitney women’s gifts—never flashy, always suggestive, and steeped in Salem’s lingering spell.

If the shifting clues around Eva’s fate, the ominous pull of Cal’s circle, and the final reversals in The Lace Reader thrilled you, The Lake of Dead Languages offers that same slow-burn unease. A Latin teacher returns to her old boarding school, where cryptic notes and resurfacing tragedies force her to reinterpret long-ago events. Like Towner’s story, the mystery tightens until the truth turns prior assumptions inside out.