If you were drawn to the unsettling sense of the uncanny and the overwhelming dread in The Great God Pan, you'll be captivated by The King in Yellow. Chambers's interconnected tales of a mysterious play that drives its readers to madness evoke a similar eerie atmosphere, blending urban settings with cosmic horror and the unknown in a way that will resonate with fans of Machen.

If you loved the way Machen hints at ancient, unknowable powers behind the veil of everyday life, The Call of Cthulhu is essential reading. Lovecraft’s tale follows Professor Angell and Francis Thurston as they piece together the terrifying puzzle of a cult and a sleeping god, masterfully evoking that same sense of forbidden knowledge and cosmic horror.

If the haunting atmosphere and the suggestion of powers beyond human comprehension fascinated you in The Great God Pan, you'll be entranced by The Willows. Blackwood crafts a tale of two friends journeying down the Danube, where the landscape itself becomes otherworldly and menacing—a masterpiece of dread and awe in the face of the unknown.

If you appreciated the ambiguous, reality-questioning horror and the unreliable accounts in The Great God Pan, The Turn of the Screw is a perfect match. James’s novella plunges you into the mind of a governess whose perceptions of ghosts and evil may be as much psychological as supernatural, leaving you to question what is truly real.

If you enjoyed the multi-layered narrative and the uncovering of a dark, supernatural presence in The Great God Pan, Dracula will grip you. Through letters, diaries, and reports, Stoker unfolds a tale of ancient evil invading the modern world, echoing Machen’s chilling blend of science, horror, and urban myth.