If the quippy back-and-forth between Vivi Jones and Rhys Penhallow—and the way their mishap curse turns Graves Glen into a romcom minefield—made you grin, you’ll love the sparks between Violet Maxwell and Lincoln Thorne in Not the Witch You Wed. A witch and a wolf-shifter fake date to satisfy supernatural politics, and every plan goes delightfully sideways. Like Vivi and Rhys teaming up to fix a mess they created, Violet and Lincoln keep colliding in witty, chemistry-laced moments that escalate into full-on swoon.

Loved how Vivi’s tipsy hex and Graves Glen’s ley-line shenanigans made the town feel enchantingly alive? The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches wraps you in that same warm, whimsical glow. When solitary witch Mika Moon takes a job tutoring three mischievous young witches at a remote house, teapots enchant themselves, spells go adorably off-script, and found-family tenderness blooms—much like Vivi and Rhys discovering there’s real heart beneath their magical misadventures.

If you were here for Vivi and Rhys’s second-chance spark—fixing a magical catastrophe while falling hard again—The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy delivers that same big-heart payoff. Grumpy marshal Hart and no-nonsense undertaker Mercy exchange anonymous letters that turn into a deep connection, all while battling uncanny creatures. The reveal hits like Vivi and Rhys admitting what’s always been between them, giving you laughter, longing, and a finale that feels earned.

If Graves Glen’s fall festival vibe and the Penhallow family obligations hooked you, Payback’s a Witch takes you to Thistle Grove, where a magical tournament stirs up old rivalries and new romance. Emmy Harlow returns home—much like Rhys—only to get pulled into scheming, spellcraft, and a sizzling love story. Expect barbed family pride, competitive enchantments, and that irresistible witchy-town atmosphere you loved in The Ex Hex.

If the close-knit feel of Graves Glen—where Vivi and Rhys fix a very local problem and everyone’s watching—won you over, The Dead Romantics offers that same intimate pull. Ghostwriter Florence Day returns to her hometown for a funeral, only to face grief, ghosts, and an unexpected connection with her (deceased?) editor. It’s tender, funny, and tightly centered on relationships and healing, echoing the personal stakes that made Vivi and Rhys’s reunion so satisfying.