If the relentless, suffocating atmosphere of The Dreams in the Witch House left you enthralled, you'll be mesmerized by The Fisherman. As Abe and Dan venture into Dutchman's Creek, the sinister history of the place—and the cosmic horror lurking beneath—echo Lovecraft's chilling sense of the unknown, plunging you into a tale where reality unravels and dread builds with every page.

If you enjoyed Walter Gilman's obsession with arcane mathematics and the lure of forbidden truths, Revival will captivate you. Stephen King's tale of a minister-turned-madman conducting terrifying experiments into the afterlife delivers the same blend of science, the occult, and cosmic terror, with a protagonist drawn irresistibly toward knowledge best left unknown.

If Gilman's slow, unnerving unraveling of reality hooked you in The Dreams in the Witch House, House of Leaves offers a labyrinthine plunge into psychological horror. As Johnny Truant and the Navidson family confront a house that defies logic and sanity, you'll experience a multi-layered narrative that blurs the line between perception and madness, much like Lovecraft's most disturbing tales.

If the eerie, enclosed rooms and strange angles of Gilman's Arkham boarding house drew you in, We Have Always Lived in the Castle will delight you with its focus on two sisters isolated in their decaying family home. The story hums with unease and supernatural overtones, inviting you to lose yourself in a world as unsettlingly confined as Lovecraft's.

If you appreciated how The Dreams in the Witch House weaves mathematics with ancient witchcraft, Fledgling offers a fresh take—melding genetics, myth, and horror. Shori, an amnesiac vampire, must piece together her identity while uncovering the scientific and mythological roots of her existence, creating a world as hauntingly mysterious and richly layered as Lovecraft's.