If you loved how Barclay is thrust into a magical apprenticeship and must prove himself through a series of escalating trials in The Accidental Apprentice, you'll be captivated by Nevermoor: The Trials of Morrigan Crow. Morrigan faces a string of magical challenges to earn her place in the Wunderous Society, with each trial ramping up the tension and forcing her to grow. The goal-driven plot keeps the pages turning as Morrigan races against the odds.

If you enjoyed the camaraderie and teamwork between Barclay and his friends as they navigate the Wilds, you'll appreciate the lively ensemble in On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness. Siblings Janner, Tink, and Leeli each play crucial roles in the adventure, bringing their unique strengths and personalities to the quest. Their banter and bonds add warmth and excitement to the story.

If Barclay’s transformation from an ordinary apprentice to a confident, self-reliant hero resonated with you, Furthermore will be a delight. Alice, a girl with no color in a world where color is magic, embarks on a fantastical quest that challenges her self-doubt and helps her embrace her uniqueness. The personal growth and emotional depth echo Barclay’s own journey.

If the immersive world of magical beasts, guilds, and Wilds in The Accidental Apprentice drew you in, you’ll love the vibrant Bureau of Supernatural Affairs in Amari and the Night Brothers. The story is packed with inventive magical systems, secret societies, and hidden wonders, making every chapter a new discovery for readers who crave richly built fantastical settings.

If you found the tone of The Accidental Apprentice uplifting—full of hope, kindness, and the promise of belonging—The Girl Who Drank the Moon will enchant you. Luna’s journey is suffused with warmth as she learns about her magical powers and is surrounded by quirky, loving companions. The hopeful atmosphere and gentle humor make it a comforting and inspiring read.