If you loved the playful tone and clever humor in Spellsinger—especially Jon-Tom's fish-out-of-water moments and odd-couple banter with Mudge the otter—you'll be delighted by The Color of Magic. Pratchett's Discworld debut is packed with absurd situations, witty dialogue, and a bumbling tourist (Twoflower) paired with a reluctant wizard (Rincewind). The book pokes fun at fantasy tropes while providing plenty of laughs and magical misadventures.

If Jon-Tom's magical, musical mishaps and the overall sense of enchantment in Spellsinger charmed you, The Last Unicorn will capture your heart. Beagle's tale is full of gentle, whimsical magic, memorable magical creatures, and a bittersweet yet hopeful tone. The story's sense of wonder and its playful treatment of fantasy conventions make it a perfect companion to Foster's work.

If you enjoyed Jon-Tom's accidental journey from ordinary student to accidental hero on a mission to save the world, The Book of Three offers a similar vibe. Taran is a young assistant pig-keeper thrust into an epic adventure, gathering quirky allies along the way. The book is full of heart, humor, and a clear quest, making it a classic for fans of goal-driven fantasy plots.

If the cast of memorable animal companions in Spellsinger—from the wise wizard Clothahump to the irrepressible otter Mudge—was a highlight, you'll revel in Redwall. Jacques's beloved fantasy features a lively community of anthropomorphic animals who band together to defend their home. The camaraderie, varied personalities, and epic battles make it a treat for anyone who loves a strong ensemble cast.

If you were drawn to the blend of lighthearted adventure, quirky characters, and tongue-in-cheek storytelling in Spellsinger, then The Princess Bride is sure to enchant you. Goldman's novel weaves together swashbuckling action, memorable one-liners, and a magical world that doesn't take itself too seriously—much like Jon-Tom's escapades.