If you loved how Bronwyn, Nate, Addy, and Cooper sift through texts, alibis, and Simon’s About That posts to crack the Bayview mystery, you’ll click with Pip Fitz-Amobi’s capstone investigation into Andie Bell and Sal Singh. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder mixes interview transcripts, research notes, and digital breadcrumbs into a propulsive, clue-driven case that scratches the same whodunit itch—right down to how every secret in town threatens to blow the investigation wide open.

Hooked by the jaw-drop reveals behind Simon’s death and how Bayview’s suspects aren’t what they seem? We Were Liars delivers that same rug-pull satisfaction. On a private island, Cadence Sinclair and her cousins piece through a past summer no one wants to talk about; when the truth arrives, it reframes every conversation and memory—just like discovering what really happened in that detention room changes how you read every scene in One of Us Is Lying.

If Bayview High’s lockers, labs, and gossip mill made the mystery feel tantalizingly close to home, Ellingham Academy will pull you in. Stevie Bell enrolls at the quirky prep school to solve its infamous kidnapping by the note-sending "Truly, Devious"—and a fresh death on campus puts her sleuthing on the clock. The mix of clever clues, campus dynamics, and pressure-cooker stakes echoes the way the Bayview Four turn detention into a crime scene and the school day into a hunt for the truth.

Loved how each Bayview narrator brings a different edge—Bronwyn’s brains, Nate’s street smarts, Addy’s reinvention, Cooper’s cool under fire—to the same case? In The Naturals, Cassie joins an FBI program with other gifted teens—human lie detector Lia, emotion-reader Michael, pattern-mind Sloane, and profiler Dean—to hunt a serial killer. The team chemistry, secrets, and high-stakes deductions deliver the same ensemble magic that made the Bayview crew so addictive.

If the tight Bayview setting—where Simon’s app, a single detention, and a handful of friendships ripple through the whole town—hooked you, Little Monsters brings that same intimate tension. When Kacey’s friend Bailey vanishes, the search turns up party rumors, secret meetups, and buried resentments. The way shifting loyalties and whispered messages peel back layers will remind you of how every Bayview secret—cheating, relationships, hidden identities—pushes the investigation somewhere darker.