If you loved how Deirdre’s ordinary world kept fraying at the edges—strange clovers, music that beckons the inhuman, and the Faerie Queen’s assassins stepping out of the shadows—you’ll click with Tithe. Kaye stumbles into warring faerie courts in New Jersey, where deals are as sharp as knives and glamours peel back to reveal teeth. That same mix of gritty suburbia and perilous fae politics that surrounded Dee and Luke powers every chapter here.

You were drawn to Dee and Luke’s charged, forbidden connection—an assassin ordered to kill her becoming the boy she can’t let go. In Wwicked Lovely, Aislinn has always seen faeries and wants nothing to do with them, but the Summer King won’t stop circling her. The tension between desire and danger echoes that aching push–pull you felt when Luke chose Dee over the Queen’s command.

If the ancient rules behind Dee’s cloverhand gift and the Faerie Queen’s lethal etiquette fascinated you, An Enchantment of Ravens doubles down on that lore. When painter Isobel offends an autumn prince with a portrait, she’s swept into the Fair Folk’s realm where every compliment is a contract and mistakes can be fatal—much like the perilous bargains shadowing Dee’s performances and Luke’s oath-bound duty.

If you liked how Lament stayed close to Dee, Luke, and James—just a handful of teens navigating deadly fae attention—The Replacement delivers that same intimate creep. Mackie knows something is wrong with his steel-town home and with himself; what lurks under the hill keeps taking children. The close-knit focus and slow encroachment of the uncanny will feel like the way danger closed in on Dee after the competition and those unsettling four-leaf omens.

If the way magic worked in Lament—the cloverhand’s luck, music as spellcraft, the Queen’s orders threading through reality—enchanted you because it felt uncanny and unpinnable, Gaiman’s The Ocean at the End of the Lane will hit that same nerve. The narrator wanders into a quiet English lane where the Hempstock women bend rules no one can quite name; the menace feels like the unseen blades behind Dee’s songs and Luke’s oath, beautiful and terrifying at once.